Post Traumatic Stress Disorder

Post Traumatic Stress Disorder


without comments


There Is A Longstanding Debate Between Psychiatrist Vs Psychologist

Those who have struggled with Mental Illness have been the recipients of stigmatization, cruelty, and fear up until fairly recently. It was only in the twentieth century that medicine has begun to tackle Mental Issues in a meaningful way thanks to the work of countless physicians compiling the diagnostic bible known as the DSM-IV which catalogs all manner of pathological symptomology that allows for patients to be diagnosed and treated. When it comes to be treated by a psychiatrist vs Psychologist, many patients remain in the dark.

The largest difference between both fields is education. Psychiatrists are doctors and have completed medical school, as well as rotations into all departments, before entering into a psychiatric residency. The training and sheer scope of knowledge these doctors have is levels above what a psychologist has.

The largest different between both is education. Psychiatrists are physicians in the same way that an oncologist or surgeon is a physician, in that they have completed the arduous task of medical school, as well as their residencies. To commit yourself to the path of psychiatry is to commit yourself to upwards of eight years of schooling.

The two approaches are different, but only from their base and they each have their pros. Psychiatrists are clinical and approach Mental Disease as a imbalance of chemicals and hormones that flow through the brain. Psychologists, on the other hand, look at man as a being that reacts to stimuli according to a certain series of rules.

Depending on the issues that a particular patient has, it may be necessary to go to a psychiatrist first and foremost for the simple reason that they are the ones that can prescribe pills. With their training in pharmacology, they understand how different levels and compounds can have an effect on the brain and, subsequently, the behavior of those that are suffering. While the therapists cannot prescribe medication, their methods have proven to be successful in a number of cases.

These do not include things like Schizophrenia or Bipolar Disorder which are tied to serious chemical imbalances and must be regulated by medication since, without pills, many patients can become a danger to themselves or others. There has never been a case in which a schizophrenic has simply talked away the voices and hallucinations in their mind. Some cases demand pharmacological intervention.

That is not to say that patients should be afraid of doubling up – they shouldn’t. In fact, there has been extensive research to suggest that the efficacy of drugs is increased when paired with behavioral therapy. A therapist is trained and continually comes into contact with a particular cross section of patients that fall into their specialty which may not be the case with a physician.

The debate between psychiatrist vs psychologist is likely to continue unabated within the academic realm. It is up to patients to be informed of their own conditions and the options they can take advantage of when it comes to getting better. The only thing that matters at all in this debate is the successful treatment of individuals who are struggling to live full and productive lives.
The Avalanches – ‘Frontier Psychiatrist’

Did you like this? Share it:

Written by Post Traumatic Stress Disorder

August 12th, 2012 at 1:26 pm

  • About Us
  • Disclosure/Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact Us
  • Post Traumatic Stress Disorder
  • 2013
  • 2012
  • 2011
  • Copy Protected by Chetan's WP-Copyprotect.